I guessed right

 Oftentimes when digging through dime boxes, it comes to a matter of guesswork. Do I have a certain card of a player?  Do I need a regular or Chrome version of a card?  Wantlists can help out immensely with this, but as a team collector of the Rays and Tigers, and a player collector of 50+ guys, it often times comes down to guesswork. A good amount of the time, I guess wrong and end up with some doubles. I’m sure it happens a decent amount of time with team collectors who don’t lug around a phone book sized list. It’s just one of the things card collectors deal with. 

I kind of wanted to go to K n T’s one more time on Tuesday, as it was the last day off before school starts again, and I was able to go, although I had the little one in hand again. He was a little more hyper this time, and I had to remind him not to spin on the chairs and keep his feet on the ground. 

While at the shop, I was able to add some needs to my collection, but not without the doubles. 

While this stack makes it look like my guessing game was off, I can assure you that it wasn’t that bad. Let’s look at the keepers, and I’ll explain why. 

For the favorite players, I was pretty good with the guessing. The Brady Anderson, Rob Ducey, Nick Fortes, Mason Miller, Max Scherzer, and Jonathan Schoop pickups were all guesses. The ‘95 Emotion and Stadium Club cards were hit and miss, with a few new ones making it. Both team sets are 1 card short, I believe. 

The 1998 Upper Deck set is where I struck gold. The set was released in 3 series. I have a good number of series 1 as a friends dad collected it and gave me just about everything from that series that he had that wasn’t an insert. I purchased a few series 2 packs, and maybe 1 series 3 pack, so those were on the thin side in my Tigers binder. Fortunately for me, there were a few chunks of 1998 Upper Deck in the dime boxes the last 3 times I went to the shop, and my 1998 Upper Deck Tigers team set is now complete. I don’t even think that the 1990, 1991, or 1992 UD Tigers sets are complete, so that is a cool accomplishment. The 1998 Upper Deck set is a vastly underrated set. The design is cool, despite sometimes having names and teams being hard to read. All-Stars, retiring players, and rookies all have a circle emblem notating that at the top, and there are some short print Eminent Prestige cards that are somewhat tough (1 in 4 packs), but only 3 of them, so they are attainable. The Manning, Baez, and Rainer were right guesses, as was the Nate Lowe. I have seen the 2019 Topps Update Josh Lowe card enough to know that something was off with the photo of the one in the dime box, and sure enough, I pulled an SP. The last correct guess of the photo was the ‘23 Donruss Kyle Manzardo. I knew I had a parallel, but wasn’t sure if I had the base version. 

The first part of this group had some good guesses, and some bad ones. I could’ve sworn I had the ‘24 Chrome Curtis Mead, but I didn’t. The ‘23 Jonathan Aranda was a dupe, but the way he has performed this year, I’m happy to add it to my rookie card binder. I swear I picked up a Chrome of the Colt Keith Rookie Debut card and that TCDB said I needed the base Chrome, but I remember picking it up from SportLots. I picked one up, and sure enough, it was a double. I’m still not sure what the Chrome card I need of Keith. Perhaps a parallel?

The best guessing came with 1999 Stadium Club and some Heritage sets. I had remembered that the 2001 Stadium Club sets had SPs that were draft picks and prospects, but wasn’t sure about 1999, so I took a gamble. Turns out the ‘99 set did, and I netted 3 more. 

The Heritage were the biggest guessing gamble for me. I knew one of the recent years of Heritage had SPs that were numbered 1-100, not 401-500, but wasn’t quite sure. There was a chunk of the 2023 set that had random cards numbered in the 400s and less than 100. I gambled that 2023 had SPs numbered 401-500, and I guessed RIGHT!!  Even picked up a few dupes of SPs. There were only 2 of the 2025 Heritage set that were SPs, but I’m still happy to add 2 more. I also had to guess on some of the high number SP numbers. I wasn’t sure if they started at 700, and saw about 3 copies of 2023 Heritage #700, but didn’t pick it up. I should have, as it was in fact an SP, but maybe the next time I go back it will still be there. I normally don’t go through Heritage stuff unless it’s the beginning of the year and I need Rays and Tigers, so I’m glad I decided to look. The SPs will help me out with some TCDB trades as well as helping out fellow bloggers trying to complete some Heritage sets. 

The last batch involved some bad guesswork. The Mojo refractor was a dupe. I found a stack of 1992 O-Pee-Chee, and dug out the Dodgers and Braves, hoping Night Owl and Johnny’s Trading Spot needed them, and according to their wantlists, I don’t believe they do. Oh well. Not bad cards to pick up for 10 cents. There were 3 pickups of guys who haven’t got much cardboard. Bobby Chouinard only has 5 major cards, a 1996 Bowman’s Best, a 1997 Fleer, 1997 Topps, a 1997 Ultra, and the 1997 Upper Deck I picked up. The next guy, Curt Lyons, stumped me. I followed baseball die hard from around 1996-2011, and you would be hard pressed to find a random player you could tell me about that I hadn’t heard of. I can tell you about Brett Hinchcliffe, Brandon Reed, Stephen Smitherman, Kevin Polcovich, and other random names. But I had never freaking heard of Curt Lyons until picking up his 1997 Upper Deck from a dime box. He has an autograph insert from 1996 Bowman, and 1997 Circa card, a 1997 Metal Universe insert, and the 1997 Upper Deck card. Ron Witmeyer could be a candidate for Night Owl’s 1 card wonders, but I’ll let him be the judge. As far as major brands, he just has the 1992 Stadium Club you see here, and a 1992 Topps MLB Debut card, a random boxed set. Other than that, just minor league cards. 

The only Topps needs I found were the 1977 Rodriguez and 2010 Paulino. I always like 1992 ToppsGold cards, and the Templeton was a need. It is also his sunset card. Joe Randa is always a favorite of mine. Back in 2004 or 2005, he was a free agent, and I had added him on MySpace, and he put out a bulletin saying that he was debating on signing with the Pirates or Yankees. I sent him a message begging him not to go to the evil Yankee$, and he surprisingly messaged me back and told me that he was weighing out options and that he was surprised how strongly I felt about it. I like to think that I helped keep him from signing with the Yankee$ and got him to become a Pirate. 

Chad Mottola is the guy helping the Rays hit .200 and under, and the Rays aren’t planning on firing him anytime soon, so I pick up his cards for potential autographs when I see them. I told Kyler how I got autographs of Sandy Alomar Jr and Sr, so I picked up the 1997 Upper Deck of Junior. Kevin Witt was a nice guy when he was with Detroit. I have a few of his game used bats, so I picked up his ‘99 Fleer Warning Track parallel card. I don’t know how the ‘06 Bowman Gold Miguel Perez card got in my stack, but I’ve seen him play, so I’m cool with it. 

The best part about the trip was that it was only 5 bucks. He would’ve done 10 had I used a card, but I had a crisp 5 dollar bill burning a hole in my wallet, and it served its purpose. That included 1 card from the dollar bin, a 2024 Topps Blue Tyler Glassnow. For all of those SPs, I think I got a deal. Hopefully, I can be as good at the guessing game during the next trip to the shop. 

Thanks for checking out my latest post. 

-Jeremy