A few months ago I needed to find a card of Ryan Howard, as my friend Jim was going to help me get his autograph. While thumbing through cards, I was reminded that Ryan is one of a select few guys who have a rookie card without the ‘rookie logo’ during the ‘Topps rookie rules’ era. I am talking about 2006 through the present, where MLB changed the rules for card sets and only allowed players who had played an MLB game in a set, basically did away with Draft Pick subset cards, and had the ‘official MLB rookie logo’ on rookie cards. Here are a few pages that really break down what everything means.
There were some players who had instances of having a draft pick or prospect Topps card with a Topps ‘rookie card logo’ before 2006, and then had the ‘MLB rookie card logo’ on a 2006 Topps (or later) card. Justin Verlander ('05 and '06), Ryan Zimmerman ('05 and '06), Andrew McCutchen ('05 and '09) were a few I could think of off of the top of my head. I know Walter Young had a 2003 Topps and 2006 Topps card which both had rookie logos, and there were at least 1 or 2 others who had a rookie logo card in a pre-2006 set and a rookie logo card in the 2006 issue
Our case of Ryan Howard falls somewhere in between. Howard had a major card as early as 2001 with his Upper Deck Prospect Premieres rookie card.
He had a 2003 Bowman’s Best card, but no 2003 Topps Traded card. He really should’ve had one in 2002 Topps Traded in my opinion. In 2004, there was again no Howard card. Finally, in 2005, he appears on a 2005 Topps prospects subset cards along with Cole Hamels.
Hamels, in fact, is another odd case, as his rookie card was a 2003 Topps Draft Pick subset card, but without the Topps first year logo.
He appears with Howard in '05 with no logo, but then
he does have the rookie logo on his 2006 Topps card.
Back to Howard, no rookie logo on the prospect card in 2005, and none on his 2006 card.
I decided to try and find all of the ‘Topps rookie cards’ that didn’t have a RC logo in it. If you are expecting to find more big names, I hate to disappoint you, but there aren’t many, but there are a few people you have probably heard of in the 2010s. Most of the cases are just guys who had decent seasons after spending a few in the Majors, and got their first Topps card after having a few years under their belt, perhaps justifying the ‘no rookie logo’ treatment.
I will try to list each player by year, with their first Topps card, which will have no rookie logo.
2005 Topps #589 Ryan Howard/Cole Hamels
Not sure why Howard didn’t get a card in ‘02-‘04, but his first Topps card comes in 2005 and has no rookie logo.
2006 Topps #107 Mark Teahen
Mark had a few solid seasons with the A’s and the Royals. I pulled a Bowman card of him in 2002, but nothing with Topps until 2006, with no rookie logo.
2007 Topps #578 Dustin Pedroia
Pedroia came up fast through the minors and made the Red Sox in 2006, but had no ‘06 Topps Update card. He got into some 2005 Bowman branded issues, and first Topps card came in the 2007 set with no rookie logo.
2007 Topps Update #140 Ryan Spillborghs
Ryan had a few nice years with Colorado, and somehow missed out on a 2006 Update issue, perhaps because he wasn’t a big name prospect. He probably got an ‘07 card to get snuck into the set after doing well with the Rockies, but didn’t get the rookie logo on it.
2008 Topps #397 Brian Wilson
Wilson was a guy you either loved or hated. I never cared for his antics, especially when his lousy Giants beat my better Tigers team in the 2012 World Series, but I respected him as an athlete. I have a 2006 Upper Deck card of him with the rookie card logo, but nothing on his 2008 Topps issue, which was his first from the company.
2009 Topps #176 Jeff Samadrdzjia
Jeff cruised through the minors pretty quickly, perhaps explaining why he had a 2008 Topps Heritage High Number rookie card with the rookie logo, and no ‘08 Topps Update card.
2009 Topps # 416 Pablo Sandoval
Another one of those nasty Giants, Sandoval got a starting shot and became a household name pretty quickly, possibly too quickly to make it into the ‘08 Update set with a rookie logo. His logoless 2009 Topps card, instead, got to be his Topps rookie issue.
2011 Topps Update #237 Ryan Roberts
While researching Roberts, I saw that he had a card in the 2006 Topps ‘52 Rookies set with the rookie logo.
He didn’t become a regular until a few seasons after that, and finally got his first Topps card in the 2011 Update set. The card features a great photo, but no rookie logo.
2011 Topps Update #251 Justin Turner
Another guy I don’t care for, because he didn’t mask up and took a team photo in 2020 during the World Series after testing positive for COVID. His outspoken attitude kind of drives me nuts as well. He has become a good player over the years, but took a while to find his stride. I pulled a 2010 Upper Deck card of Turner, featuring their rookie logo.
His first Topps card in the 2011 Update set features no rookie logo, but at least they got him early in his career and didn’t wait until he was in LA.
2012 Topps #405 Nathan Eovaldi
Eovaldi bounced around a little before settling in with Boston, but he was on a few cards before that. Not sure why he missed out on a rookie in 2011 Update, but his ‘12 Topps version doesn’t have the logo.
2014 Topps Update #40 Stephen Vogt
Vogt got his first Topps card in the ‘14 Update set but never got a 2013 ‘true’ rookie. He was good enough to have a 2011 Bowman issue, but maybe just slipped under the radar enough to miss out on the first year rookie, so we have to settle with the 2014 Topps Update no rookie logo card being his Topps rookie card.
2015 Topps #354 Kyle Hendricks
Hendricks missed out on a 2014 Topps Update rookie card with a rookie logo. I don’t remember him being a heralded rookie, so perhaps that’s why he has the second year Topps card in 2015 with no rookie logo.
2015 Topps Update #117 Enrique ‘Kiki’ Hernandez
This card was a nemesis for me. I’m not sure why it is such an expensive card. He was on a few championship teams, but it wasn’t like he was a superstar or anything. No rookie logo, but it is technically his Topps rookie, and I believe the cheapest version I could find was for 15 bucks. It was a needed card for my ‘15 Update set, so I got it. It is one of the few instances of a non-rookie logo card that people know is a rookie, and is priced accordingly.
2016 Topps #584 Adam Duvall
Duvall put together a few good seasons once he hit the Majors, but I don’t remember him being a prospect that got very much hype. He could’ve had a 2015 Update card with a rookie logo, but Topps was really on the Kris Bryant bandwagon that year, giving him like 3 cards in the set. Duvall ends up with a 2016 non rookie logo Topps rookie. On a side note, while researching Duvall’s cards, I found out he is a Type 1 Diabetic, so I have to add his cards to my favorite player binder as I will be collecting him now.
2018 Topps Update #237 Carson Kelly
I feel like somewhere between 2015 and 2020 that rookies started getting pumped into Topps sets like they were steroids going into Nelson Cruz. Somehow Kelly missed out on a 2017 Topps card with a rookie logo, didn’t end up with a logo or logoless 2018 regular issue, but ended up with a logoless 2018 Update card.
2019 Topps #415 Zach Eflin
The third to last card I found in the research, Zach is a former Ray, as are the last 2 guys. Eflin had a number of 2014 issues, like Bowman and Pro Debut, he had a 2016 Heritage card, but his first Topps issue didn’t come until 2019.
He didn’t really pitch much until 2018, but he could’ve had a rookie logo card in the 2018 Update set. By 2019, he was no longer a rookie, which probably explains why his 2019 Topps rookie doesn’t have the logo.
2024 Topps Update #102 Jason Adam
Jason pitched for a few years with little fanfare, coming up to MLB in 2018, but when he had a good year in 2024, Topps got him into the Update set. I actually saw him at the Trop that year, and got his only Rays card at the time, his 2023 Topps Rays team set issue, autographed.
I figured if he got a 2023 team card, which I believe came out before Series 2, that he should’ve had a 2023 Update rookie logo card. The 2023 team set card, like his 2024 Update one, doesn’t have the logo. Since he first debuted in 2018, I suspect that is why he didn’t have the logo.
2025 Topps #265 Ryan Thompson
The last guy I found in my research, Ryan either collects cards, or just wanted to be on one, as I remember reading that he wanted to be on a Topps card and hoped his pitching would help him get on a set. He pitched well enough with the Rays to deserve one, but had to wait until 2025 to get on one, years after making the Bigs for the first time in 2020. I had the chance to see him on Opening Day in 2023 at the Trop, and he signed a 2023 Topps custom that I made of him, and I gave him a few, helping him hold out until he got into the 2025 Topps set, albeit without the RC logo.
Well, that about does it for rookie cards without the RC logo from 2006 to now. I may have missed some or erroneously listed guys that did have RC logo cards, so I would love to hear any corrections or additions I need to make.
Be on the lookout for some of these cards. You might be able to get a cheap rookie of a guy because the RC logo is missing. Not that any of these guys are stars, but some are household names.
On the other hand, there are ones like the '15 Kiki Hernandez rookie and the '07 Pedroia rookie that people know are technically rookies, and are priced at a premium.
I hope you enjoyed this post on wierd Topps rookies that don't have the rookie logo.
Thanks for checking it out.
-Jeremy


























